Defenders of the Truth: The Battle for Science in the Sociobiology Debate and Beyond

Description

For the last twenty-five years, sociobiologists have come under continuous attack by a group of left-wing academics, who have accused the former of dubious and politically dangerous science. Many have taken the critics' charges at face value. But have the critics been right? And what aretheir own motivations? This book strives to set the record straight. It shows that the criticism has typically been unfair. Still, it cannot be dismissed as 'purely politically motivated'. It turns out that the critics and the sociobiologists live in different worlds of taken-for-grantedscientific and moral convictions. The conflict over sociobiology is best interpreted as a drawn-out battle about the nature of 'good science' and the social responsibility of the scientist, while it touches on such grand themes as the unity of knowledge, the nature of man, and free will anddeterminism. The author has stepped right into the hornet's nest of claims and counterclaims, moral concerns, metaphysical beliefs, political convictions, strawmen, red herrings, and gossip, gossip, gossip. She listens to the protagonists - but also to theircolleagues. She checks with 'arbiters'. She plays the devil's advocate. And everyone is eager to tell her the truth - as they see it. The picture that emerges is a different one from the standard view of the sociobiology debate as a politically motivated nature-nurture conflict. Instead, we areconfronted with a world of scientific and moral long-term agendas, for which the sociobiology debate became a useful vehicle. Behind the often nasty attacks, however, were shared Enlightenment concerns for universal truth, morality and justice. The protagonists were all defenders of the truth - itwas just that everyone's truth was different. Defenders of the Truth provides a fascinating insight into the world of science. It follows the sociobiology controversy as it erupted at Harvard in 1975 until today, both in the US and the UK. But the story goes more deeply, for instance in itsaccount of the circumstances surrounding W.D. Hamilton's famous 1964 paper on inclusive fitness, and on the connections of the sociobiology debate to the Human Genome project and the Science Wars. General readers and academics alike will find much to savour in this book.

Get the book

Amazon.com

Search the book

eBay.com

Search the book

Other editions

• 

  Defenders of the Truth: The Sociobiology Debate

  • 2000
  • 493 pages
  • Paperback
  • Oxford University Press, USA

Similar books

• 

  Interviews with William Carlos Williams: "speaking Straight Ahead"

  By William Carlos Williams

  Dr. Williams discusses his own work and that of such contemporaries as Pound and Eliot and reveals his thoughts on a wide variety of twentieth-century concerns

• 

  與諾貝爾獎得主一起穿越時空的十二堂科學課──橫跨物理、化學、生物，啟動自主學習，掌握科學閱讀素養力

  By 巴里•馬歇爾

  絕對不要忽略平凡的事物，那可能是你獲得諾貝爾獎的線索 諾貝爾生醫獎得主巴里•馬歇爾親撰 諾貝爾獎得主親自對話，示範科學素養 建立閱讀理解的最佳讀物 培養自主學習能力 ...

• 

  荷爾蒙

  By 蘭蒂．胡特．艾普斯坦

  科學新聞》雜誌（Science News）2018年度選書 《富比世》（Forbes）雜誌2018年腦科學必讀選書 暢銷書《基因：人類最親密的歷史》作者辛達塔．穆克吉盛讚 我們是怎麼發現荷爾蒙的？ ...

• 

  Encyclopedia of Human Ecology: A-H

  By Julia R. Miller

  Amy Griffin Monica Mouton Sanders M.Angela Casady Jennifer Smith Burden Tom Luster See also: Adolescent Pregnancy and Prevention; Prenatal Decision Making by Adolescents; Sexual Abstinence References and Further Reading Child Trends.

• 

  Chemical Creativity: Ideas from the Work of Woodward, Hückel, Meerwein, and Others

  By Jerome A. Berson

  Thus, Turner's study (ref. 83) makes a case that Hitler's accession was by no means inevitable and that ... X as with so much in the mythology of his Third Reich, the belief that January 30”, 1933, marked a seizure of power was spurious ...

• 

  Environment, Energy, and Society: Exemplary Works

  By Craig R. Humphrey, Tammy L. Lewis, Frederick H. Buttel

  We also present the Pearson r coefficient on the same two relationships , which will facilitate the comparison we will make next . In using the Pearson r statistic , these two economic trade - off questions continue to be positively ...

• 

  解密雙螺旋: DNA結構發現者華生的告白

  By 華生 James D. Watson

  我們多次要求資訊與圖片,札里洛有無窮的耐心,無論多麼晦澀難解,他都能迅速回應。在為威爾金斯的論文編目時,倫敦國王學院的奧佛(Christopher Olver)非常幫忙,主管為布洛維爾(Geoff Browell)。克里克的論文保存於維康信託基金會(Wellcome Trust), ...

• 

  Wheat Production and Utilization: Systems, Quality and the Environment

  By Mike J. Gooding, W. Paul Davies

  Newman , G. ( 1992 ) Future prospects for whole - crop cereals in the UK . ... In : Hewitt , H.G. , Tyson , D. , Hollomon , D.W. , Smith , J.M. , Davies , W.P. and Dixon K.R. ( eds ) A Vital Role for Fungicides in Cereal Production .

• 

  The Ecology and Management of Wetlands: Volume 2: Management, Use and Value of Wetlands

  By Donal D. Hook

  Volume 2: Management, Use and Value of Wetlands Donal D. Hook, W. H. Mckee Jr, H. K. Smith, J. Gregory, V. G. Burrell Jr, ... Chapter Thirty - four AQUACULTURE IN MANGROVE WETLANDS : A PERSPECTIVE FROM SOUTHEAST ASIA James P. McVey ...

• 

  African American Firsts in Science & Technology

  By Raymond B. Webster

  ... George W. 318 Neal , Lonnie G. 126 , 312 Nickerson , William J. 11 Nokes , Clarence 121 Page , Lionel F. 356 ... Wanda Anne A. 150 Small , Isadore , III 135 Smart , Brinay 106 Smith , Jonathan S. , II 312 Smith , Morris Leslie 312 ...