Slavery and the Numbers Game: A Critique of Time on the Cross
- ISBN-10
- 0252071514
- ISBN-13
- 9780252071515
- Category
- Enslaved persons
- Pages
- 183
- Language
- English
- Published
- 2003
- Publisher
- University of Illinois Press
- Author
- Herbert George Gutman
Description
This detailed analysis of slavery in the antebellum South was written in 1975 in response to the prior year's publication of Robert Fogel and Stanley Engerman's controversial Time on the Cross, which argued that slavery was an efficient and dynamic engine for the southern economy and that its success was due largely to the willing cooperation of the slaves themselves. Noted labor historian Herbert G. Gutman was unconvinced, even outraged, by Fogel and Engerman's arguments. In this book he offers a systematic dissection of Time on the Cross, drawing on a wealth of data to contest that book's most fundamental assertions. A benchmark work of historical inquiry, Gutman's critique sheds light on a range of crucial aspects of slavery and its economic effectiveness. Gutman emphasizes the slaves' responses to their treatment at the hands of slaveowners. He shows that slaves labored, not because they shared values and goals with their masters, but because of the omnipresent threat of 'negative incentives, ' primarily physical violence. In his introduction to this new edition, Bruce Levine provides a historical analysis of the debate over Time on the Cross. Levine reminds us of the continuing influence of the latter book, demonstrated by Robert W. Fogel's 1993 Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences, and hence the importance and timeliness of Gutman's critique.
Get the book
Other editions
-
- 1975
- 183 pages
- Paperback
- University of Illinois Press
-
- 1975-01-01
- 183 pages
- Paperback
- Urbana : University of Illinois Press
Similar books
-
Time on the Cross: The Economics of American Negro Slavery
By Robert William FogelEmploys quantitative analyses to correct long-standing historical beliefs concerning the inefficiency of the slave system, the dispersion of Black families, and the material poverty of slaves
-
The Numbers Game: Why Everything You Know about Soccer is Wrong
By Chris Anderson, David SallySimon Kuper, "A Football Revolution,” Financial Times, 17 June 2011; www.ft.com/cms/s/2/947Idb52-97bb-IIeo-9C37-0044feab49a. html#axzziqzPfmj6H. IO. II. I2. I3. 3. Ayton and Braennberg (2008). Focusing.
-
Playing the Numbers: Gambling in Harlem Between the Wars
By Shane WhiteSometimes the arrests came from further afield in the city: in October 1917, Knita Genaka, a thirty-four-year-old butler and Japanese national living on Lexington Avenue, was picked up by the police in the Hudson Terminal with ...
-
The Numbers Game: A Novel
By Danielle SteelIn this surprising, illuminating novel, Danielle Steel gives us a warmhearted portrait of people driven by their emotions, life experiences, and loyalties, who realize that it’s never too late to turn a new page and start again.
-
The Black Family in Slavery and Freedom, 1750-1925
By Herbert G. GutmanAn exhaustively researched history of black families in America from the days of slavery until just after the Civil War.
-
Perspectives and Irony in American Slavery
By Harry P. OwensFurthermore , two significant analyses of Time on the Cross — Herbert Gutman's Slavery and the Numbers Game : A Critique of " Time on the Cross " ( 1975 ) , and a collaborative effort entitled Reckoning with Slavery : Critical Essays in ...
-
Objectivity Is Not Neutrality: Explanatory Schemes in History
By Thomas L. HaskellA Critique of the ' New Economic History ? ” ( Rochester conference paper ) ; Gutman , Slavery and the Numbers Game , 66-69 ; Sutch , “ The Treatment Received by American Slaves , ” 20-24 , in manuscript ; Reckoning with Slavery ...
-
Slavery in the United States: A Social, Political, and Historical Encyclopedia
By Junius P. RodriguezGutman, in Slavery and the Numbers Game (1975), charged them with underrepresenting the large plantations, incorrectly calculating data, and then making erroneous as- sumptions based on their misinterpretation of the evidence.
-
Saltwater Slavery: A Middle Passage from Africa to American Diaspora
By Stephanie E. SmallwoodAlbert van Dantzig and Adam Jones ( Oxford : Oxford University Press , 1987 ) , p . ... 277-312 ; Martin W. Lewis and Karen E. Wigen , The Myth of the Continents : A Critique of Metageography ( Berkeley : University of California Press ...
-
Handbook Global History of Work
By Marcel van der Linden, Karin HofmeesterAmong the many critical responses, the best known is that of Herbert G. Gutman, whose Slavery and the Numbers Game focused with particular emphasis on estimates of the number of beatings received by slaves.23 Research on slavery and ...