Reliability in Cognitive Neuroscience: A Meta-Meta-Analysis

ISBN-10: 0262018527
ISBN-13: 9780262018524
Category: Brain
Pages: 238
Language: English
Published: 2013
Publisher: MIT Press
Author: William R. Uttal

Description

A review of the empirical evidence shows that unreliability of research findings relating brain images and cognitive processes is widespread in cognitive neuroscience. Cognitive neuroscientists increasingly claim that brain images generated by new brain imaging technologies reflect, correlate, or represent cognitive processes. In this book, William Uttal warns against these claims, arguing that, despite its utility in anatomic and physiological applications, brain imaging research has not provided consistent evidence for correlation with cognition. Uttal bases his argument on an extensive review of the empirical literature, pointing to variability in data not only among subjects within individual experiments but also in the new meta-analytical approach that pools data from different experiments. This inconsistency of results, he argues, has profound implications for the field, suggesting that cognitive neuroscientists have not yet proven their interpretations of the relation between brain activity captured by macroscopic imaging techniques and cognitive processes; what may have appeared to be correlations may have only been illusions of association. He supports the view that the true correlates are located at a much more microscopic level of analysis: the networks of neurons that make up the brain. Uttal carries out comparisons of the empirical data at several levels of data pooling, including the meta-analytical. He argues that although the idea seems straightforward, the task of pooling data from different experiments is extremely complex, leading to uncertain results, and that little is gained by it. Uttal's investigation suggests a need for cognitive neuroscience to reevaluate the entire enterprise of brain imaging-cognition correlational studies.

Get the book

Similar books

Macroneural Theories in Cognitive Neuroscience
By William R. Uttal
In this book, William R. Uttal continues his analysis and critique of theories of mind.
Real-World Applications in Cognitive Neuroscience

This perspective has led to what some have referred to the reliability paradox for several classical cognitive paradigms, including the Stroop task, Flanker task and several other widely used measures (Hedge et al., 2018).
The Year in Cognitive Neuroscience ....

The Year in Cognitive Neuroscience ....
Emerging Cognitive Neuroscience and Related Technologies
By National Research Council, Division on Engineering and Physical Sciences, Board on Behavioral
http://www.nap.edu/catalog/12177.html The National Academy of Sciences is a private, nonprofit, self-perpetuating society of distinguished scholars engaged in scientific and engineering research, dedicated to the furtherance of science ...
The Cognitive Neurosciences, sixth edition
By Michael S. Gazzaniga, George R. Mangun, David Poeppel
The hypothesis is subsequently confirmed and consolidated in long-term memory as a subsequently recoverable hypothesis through activations in the ventral striatum when it is deemed reliable. Conversely, the hypothesis is rejected and ...
The Cognitive Neuroscience of Metacognition
By Christopher D. Frith, Stephen M. Fleming
Recent findings indicate that metacognitive processes are similarly sensitive to this hierarchical structure [38]. ... Reliability. Formal accounts of categorical decisions, such as the DDM, are often illustrated by analogy to court of ...
Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience: An Introduction
By Michelle de Haan, Mark H. Johnson
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series B, Biological Sciences, 358, 459–473. Frost, D. O. (1990). ... Galaburda, A. M., Sherman, G. F., Rosen, G. D., Aboitiz, F., & Geschwind, N. (1985).
Murder in the Courtroom: The Cognitive Neuroscience of Violence
By Brigitte Vallabhajosula
This volume provides a frame of reference in which to consider the effects of cognitive abnormalities on violent behaviour and the impact on legal decision-makers.
Cognitive Neuroscience of Consciousness: A Special Issue of Cognitive Neuroscience
By Anil Seth
The book features the main schemes of the Monte Carlo method and presents various examples of its application, including queueing, quality and reliability estimations, neutron transport, astrophysics, and numerical analysis.
Cognitive Neuroscience of Human Systems: Work and Everyday Life
By Chris Forsythe, Huafei Liao, Michael Christopher Stefan Trumbo
A data-informed PIF hierarchy for modelbased human reliability analysis. Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 108, 154–174. Haynes, J.D., Sakai, K., Rees, G., Gilbert, S., Firth, C. and Passingham, R.E. (2007).