Defining Science: A Rhetoric of Demarcation
- ISBN-10
- 0299150348
- ISBN-13
- 9780299150341
- Category
- Case studies
- Pages
- 292
- Language
- English
- Published
- 1996
- Publisher
- Univ of Wisconsin Press
- Author
- Charles Alan Taylor
Description
"The most interesting entry point to the demarcation problem in science since Popper's seminal formulation."--Steve Fuller, Professor of Sociology & Social Policy, Durham University What is science? What isn't science? And who draws the line between them? These are rhetorical concerns, as Charles A. Taylor demonstrates in this ambitious book about the theoretical and cultural underpinnings of scientific practice. By showing how boundaries between "science" and "nonscience" are rhetorically constructed and socially enforced, "Defining Science" reveals the political and philosophical significance of such distinctions. Taylor examines the traditional "demarcation problem," the problem of defining the boundaries of science, as an ongoing rhetorical negotiation involving a full range of historical interests and social actors--from researchers and lab technicians to governmental and industrial patrons, program administrators, political representatives, journalists, and educators. His case studies of the recent debates over creationism and cold fusion clearly demonstrate how the rhetorical dynamics of science operate within different fields. In both cases, presented here with concision and insight, prevailing demarcations--or defining portrayals of science--emerge as far more nuanced than traditional accounts allow. Taylor analyzes traditional approaches to demarcation in science in order to incorporate their insights into his larger rhetorical view. His reformulation of philosophical, historical, and sociological accounts of science clearly illustrates the intellectual value of an interdisciplinary rhetoric of demarcation. Furthermore, Defining Science suggests how we, as a community, can positively influence future constructions of science and society. "This book confronts what is arguably the late twentieth century's definitive problem in a provocative and interesting way. It will be of interest to anyone engaged with the question of knowledge in public life."--Charles Arthur Willard, Professor and Chair of the Department of Communication, University of Louisville
Get the book
Other editions
-
- 2003-09-18
- 304 pages
- Paperback
- Cambridge University Press
Similar books
-
The Man Who Would Be Queen: The Science of Gender-Bending and Transsexualism
By J. Michael BaileyThese and other stories make it clear that there are men â€" and men who become women â€" who want only to understand themselves and the society that makes them feel like outsiders.
-
Small Sacrifices
By Ann RuleThe story of an Oregon woman convicted of shooting her three children, killing one, in 1983.
-
Stories from the Shadows: Reflections of a Street Doctor
By James J. O'ConnellDr. O'Connell's collection of stories and essays, written during thirty years of caring for homeless persons in Boston, gently illuminates the humanity and raw courage of those who struggle to survive and find meaning and hope while living ...
-
Creating the Welfare State: The Political Economy of Twentieth-century Reform
By Kim McQuaid, Edward D. BerkowitzCovering the period from the 1980s to the present, this important volume employs interdisciplinary techniques to demonstrate how politics, economics, law, and social theory merged over the course of a century of policy formulation and ...
-
Die Krankenjournale: Krankenjournal D 16 : (1817 - 1818) / Transkription von Ulrich Schuricht. Kommentarband zur Transkription / von Ulrich...
By Samuel Hahnemann, Ulrich SchurichtKrankenjournal D 16 : (1817 - 1818) / Transkription von Ulrich Schuricht. Kommentarband zur Transkription / von Ulrich ... Nach einer handschriftlichen Neubearbeitung Hahnemanns für die 6. ... ( 1991ff ) : Die Krankenjournale .
-
Cross-cultural Counseling: A Case Book
By Clemmont E. Vontress, Jake A. Johnson, Lawrence R. EppCase studies of ten clients representing many different cultural, racial, and ethnic backgrounds illustrate the subtle dimensions of counseling culturally different clients.
-
Promoting Reproductive Health: Investing in Health for Development
By Shepard Forman, Romita Ghoshreproductive health to mean " the ability of women to live from adoles- cence or marriage with reproductive choice ... Governments were encouraged to ensure equal rights to men and women within the context of Islamic teachings and were ...
-
Nationalism and Sexuality: Respectability and Abnormal Sexuality in Modern Europe
By George Lachmann MosseTraces the relationship between nationalist ideology and the normative manners, morals, and sexuality of modern Europe which emerged at the end of the 18th century.
-
Kleptomania: The Compulsion to Steal-- what Can be Done?
By Marcus Jacob GoldmanOffers compassionate, practical information and help that can be found nowhere else.
-
Witchcraft and Hysteria in Elizabethan London: Edward Jorden and the Mary Glover Case
By Michael MacDonaldReassesses and sets in its historical context Jorden's famous pamphlet. In his introduction, Michael MacDonald provides an analysis of the politics of credulity and scepticism in early modern England and Jorden's part in them.