Three Arguments Against Whole Language & why They are Wrong

ISBN-10: 0325001197
ISBN-13: 9780325001197
Category: Education
Pages: 103
Language: English
Published: 1999
Publisher: Greenwood
Author: Stephen D. Krashen

Description

Stephen Krashen, one of the country's most respected authorities on language and literacy, sets the record straight about today's reading wars, offering an incisive analysis of the three major "battle cries" of whole language critics. In a step-by-step dissection, Krashen reiterates the three arguments, then explores the most salient studies that support or refute them. CLAIM: Eye movement studies prove that readers assay text "completely," and therefore do not sample text to confirm predictions, as maintained by whole language advocates. In exploring the Eye Fixation Studies, which attempted to disprove the Goodman-Smith reading theory, Krashen reveals that study participants had no alternative but to examine every fine detail of the print. Further evidence is provided that supports the hypothesis that literacy development and comprehension are in fact closely related. CLAIM: Context interferes with reading. This is only true, says Krashen, if the context (e.g. pictures) is too rich, or "overdetermining." We also see how the results of studies supporting this claim were biased by the methodology used. CLAIM: Skill-building approaches to reading have been shown to produce better results than whole language. In fact, asserts Krashen, when whole language is correctly defined as providing comprehensible texts, it is a consistent winner. The author also skewers the national frenzy over early intervention and illustrates his point with a humorous scenario showing how "prenatal phonemic awareness testing" could be the logical outgrowth of an entirely skills-based approach! But beyond its point/counterpoint format, Three Argumentsoffers some real solutions, chief of which is making sure that all children have access to interesting reading material so they can finally achieve the standards of literacy they deserve.

Get the book

Similar books

Condemned Without a Trial: Bogus Arguments Against Bilingual Education
By Stephen D. Krashen
Here is a timely and important book for anyone concerned about the future of bilingual education in America. Written by Stephen Krashen, the nation's foremost expert on second language acquisition,...
Language, Power and Pedagogy: Bilingual Children in the Crossfire
By Jim Cummins
In addressing these issues, this volume focuses not only on issues of language learning and teaching but also highlights the ways in which power relations in the wider society affect patterns of teacher–student interaction in the ...
Bilingual Competence and Bilingual Proficiency in Child Development
By Norbert Francis
Newark, DE: International Reading Association. Goodman, Y., D. Watson, and C. Burke. 1987. ... Gough, P., W. Hoover, and C. Peterson. 1996. ... Grantham-McGregor, S., Y. B. Cheung, S. Cueto, P. Glewwe, L. Richter, and B. Strupp. 2007.
Language, Literacy, and Power in Schooling
By T. L. McCarty
However, the broader concept of literacy practices is still needed, he asserts, to link literacy events to larger social, cultural, and ideological processes. This appears to be the sense in which some researchers have applied the ...
The Power of Reading: Insights from the Research, 2nd Edition: Insights from the Research
By Stephen D. Krashen
Continuing the case for free voluntary reading set out in the book's 1993 first edition, this new, updated, and much-looked-for second edition explores new research done on the topic in the last ten years as well as looking anew at some of ...
Widening the Circle: Culturally Relevant Pedagogy for American Indian Children
By Beverly J. Klug, Patricia T. Whitfield
Since the Spanish-speaking children were in Mrs. Jenkins's first-grade classroom, Marty and Ben decided to divide their practicum hours between the two classes. Mrs. Jenkins's classroom was very traditional, what you might expect in any ...
Contemporary Readings in Literacy Education
By Barbara Moss, Marva Cappello
The readings are contextualized with introductions and discussion questions by the editors of the text. The text will help instructors to easily integrate the latest research into their course in a meaningful way.
Dimensions of Literacy: A Conceptual Base for Teaching Reading and Writing in School Settings
By Stephen B. Kucer
This popular text examines literacy from a multidimensional and interdisciplinary perspective.
Reconceptualizing Literacy in the New Age of Multiculturalism and Pluralism
By Peter B. Mosenthal, Patricia Ruggiano Schmidt
Neveryona; or, Tales of signs and cities. New York: Bantam. Delany, S.R. (1985). Flight from Neveryon. New York: Bantam. Delany, S.R. (1987). The bridge of lost desire. Arbor House. Delany, S.R. (1995). Atlantis: Three tales.
Resources in Education

Resources in Education