Popular Government and the Supreme Court: Securing the Public Good and Private Rights
- ISBN-10
- 0700607439
- ISBN-13
- 9780700607433
- Category
- Political Science / American Government / General
- Pages
- 361
- Language
- English
- Published
- 1996
- Publisher
- University Press of Kansas
- Author
- Lane V. Sunderland
Description
With quiet eloquence, Lane Sunderland argues that we must reclaim the fundamental principles of the Constitution if we are to restore democratic government to its proper role in American life. For far too long, he contends, the popular will has been held in check by an overly powerful Supreme Court using non-constitutional principles to make policy and promote its own political agendas. His work shows why this has diminished American democracy and what we can do to revive it.
Sunderland presents a strong, thoughtful challenge to the constitutional theories promoted by Ronald Dworkin, Archibald Cox, Richard Epstein, Michael Perry, John Hart Ely, Robert Bork, Philip Kurland, Laurence Tribe, Mark Tushnet, and Catharine MacKinnon—an enormously diverse group united by an apparent belief in judicial supremacy. Their theories, he demonstrates, undermine the democratic foundations of the Constitution and the power of the majority to resolve for itself important questions of justice.
Central to this enterprise is Sunderland's reconsideration of The Federalist as the first, most reliable, and most profound commentary on the Constitution. "The Federalist," he states, "is crucial because it explains the underlying theory of the Constitution as a whole, a theory that gives meaning to its particular provisions." In addition, Sunderland reexamines the Declaration of Independence and the work of Hobbes, Locke, and Montesquieu, in order to better define the nature and limits of their influence on the Framers. His reading of these works in conjunction with The Federalist shows just how far afield contemporary commentators have strayed.
Sunderland deliberately echoes and amplifies Madison's wisdom in Federalist No. 10 that the object of the Constitution is "to secure the public good and private rights . . . and at the same time to preserve the spirit and form of popular government." To attain that object, he persuasively argues, requires that the judiciary acknowledge and enforce the constitutional limitations upon its own powers. In an era loudly proclaiming the return of popular government, majority rule, and the "will of the people," that argument is especially relevant and appealing.
Get the book
Similar books
-
Public Opinion and Popular Government
By Robert WeissbergPublic Opinion and Popular Government
-
The Velvet Coup: The Constitution, the Supreme Court, and the Decline of American Democracy
By Daniel LazareArgues that the Constitution is responsible for subverting democracy in America, discussing the problems caused by the separation of powers and advocating for the end of constitutional constraints.
-
The Collected Works of William Howard Taft: Popular government and the Anti-trust Act and the Supreme Court
By William Howard TaftThe Collected Works of William Howard Taft: Popular government and the Anti-trust Act and the Supreme Court
-
Judicial Dictatorship
By William J. Quirk, Randall BridwellIn 1974 the United Steelworkers and Kaiser Aluminum included an affirmative action plan in their agreement establishing how production workers could enter into craft training. The plan reserved for black employees 50 percent of the ...
-
The Federalist Papers
By Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, John JayClassic Books Library presents this brand new edition of “The Federalist Papers”, a collection of separate essays and articles compiled in 1788 by Alexander Hamilton.
-
Meet the Supreme Court
By Drew NelsonThe Supreme Court has an important role in American government, such as keeping lawmakers in check and passing down influential decisions.
-
The Ninth Amendment and the Politics of Creative Jurisprudence: Disparaging the Fundamental Right of Popular Control
By Marshall DeRosaIn this volume, Marshall DeRosa provides a thorough analysis of Supreme Court unenumerated rights policy and offers suggestions toward reestablishing American federalism as envisioned by the framers of the Constitution.
-
The Supreme Court and American Constitutionalism
By Ken Masugi, Bradford P. WilsonIn this important book, fourteen of America's leading constitutional scholars assess the Supreme Court's performance expounding the animating principles of American constitutionalism.
-
We the People of Montana--: The Workings of a Popular Government
By James J. LopachWe the People of Montana--: The Workings of a Popular Government
-
A History of Civil Rights Through Legislation: Constitutional Amendments, Laws, Supreme Court Decisions & Key Foreign Policy Acts: Declaration of...
By U.S. Congress, U.S. Government, U.S. Supreme CourtThis collection incorporates the crucial democratic principles on which our identity as Americans is based.