The War Within the Union High Command: Politics and Generalship During the Civil War
- ISBN-10
- 0700612637
- ISBN-13
- 9780700612635
- Category
- History / Military / General
- Pages
- 300
- Language
- English
- Published
- 2003
- Publisher
- University Press of Kansas
- Author
- Thomas Joseph Goss
Description
With Union armies poised to launch the final campaigns against the Confederacy in 1864, three of its five commanders were "political generals"—appointed officers with little or no military training. Army chief of staff Henry Halleck thought such generals jeopardized the lives of men under their command and he and his peers held them in utter contempt. Historians have largely followed suit.
Thomas Goss, however, offers a new and more positive assessment of the leadership qualities of these Northern commanders. In the process, he cuts through the stereotypes of political generals as superfluous and largely inept tacticians, ambitious schemers, and military failures. Goss examines the reasons why the selection process yielded so many generals who lacked military backgrounds and explores the tense and often bitter relationships among political and professional officers to illuminate the dynamics of Union generalship during the war. As this book reveals, professional generals viewed the war as a military problem requiring battlefield solutions, while appointees (and President Lincoln) focused more emphatically on the broader political contours of the struggle. The resulting friction often eroded Northern morale and damaged the North's war effort.
Goss challenges the traditional idea that success was measured only on the battlefield by demonstrating significant links between military success and the achievement of the Union's political objectives. Examining commanders like Benjamin Butler, Nathaniel Banks, John McClernand, John Fremont, and Franz Sigel, Goss shows how many filled vital functions by raising troops, boosting homefront morale, securing national support for the war—and sometimes even achieving significant success on the battlefield. Comparing these generals with their professional counterparts reveals that all had vital roles to play in helping Lincoln prosecute the war and that West Pointers, despite their military training, were not necessarily better prepared for waging war.
Whether professional or appointed, Goss reminds us, all generals could be considered political inasmuch as war is a continuation of politics by other means. He shows us that far more was asked of Union commanders than to simply win battles and in so doing urges a new appreciation of those appointed leaders who were thrust into the maelstrom of the Civil War.
Get the book
Similar books
-
空间武器地球战
By （美）普雷斯顿（PrestonB.）, （美）达纳·约翰逊（Dana J.Johnson）, （美）肖恩·爱德华兹（Sean J.A.Edwards）外层空间争夺是美国人梦想中一个重要主题，在外层空间部署毁灭性的大规模武器，称霸地球成为美国当局的目标，本书为这一目标作了说明。
-
Civil War Generalship: The Art of Command
By W. J. Wood... 103 , Tuscumbia , Ala . , 197 , 199 , 200 184 Starling , Lyne , 165 Valley Head , Ga . , 105 Steedman , James B. ... 107 , Williams , Alpheus S. , 60 , 61 , 63 , 76 108 , 110 , 120 , 121 , 145 , 146 , 149–151 , Wilson , James H.
-
Chronicles of Border Warfare. New Edition, Edited and Annotated by R. G. Thwaites ... with the Addition of a Memoir...
By Alexander Scott Withers, Lyman Copeland Draper, Reuben Gold ThwaitesThis is a curated and comprehensive collection of the most important works covering matters related to national security, diplomacy, defense, war, strategy, and tactics.
-
Chronicles of Border Warfare. New Edition, Edited and Annotated by R. G. Thwaites ... with the Addition of a Memoir...
By Alexander Scott Withers, Lyman Copeland Draper, Reuben Gold ThwaitesThis work has been selected by scholars as being culturally important, and is part of the knowledge base of civilization as we know it.
-
Anglo-American Shipbuilding in World War II: A Geographical Perspective
By Daniel Todd, Michael LindbergMoss and Hume , p . 352 . 34. The data are described in N. S. Ross , " Employment in Shipbuilding and ShipRepairing in Great Britain , " Journal of the Roval Statistical Society , Series A , 115 , 1952 , pp . 524-533 . 35.
-
Iraq and the International Oil System: Why America Went to War in the Gulf
By Stephen C. PelletiereBut roughly at the same time as Samuel , a British engineer , W. D. Pearson , made the attempt . In 1901 Pearson — while building a railway along Mexico's east coast — espied standing pools of oil at Tampico , and this led him to seek ...
-
On the Banks of the Suez: An Israeli General's Personal Account of the Yom Kippur War
By Avraham AdanMilitary Misfortune by Eliot A. Cohen & John Gooch 296 pages , The Free Press New York , N.Y. , 1990. $ 22.95 ISBN 01-02-906060-5 Why do competent armies fail ? What explains these “ lost victories , ” as Field ...
-
The Ten Cents War: Chile, Peru, and Bolivia in the War of the Pacific, 1879-1884
By Bruce W. FarcauHe installed three 70 - pounders , a 150 - pounder . and a pair of 100 - pound Parrott rifled guns atop the Morro with a 250 - pound French Vavasseur and another four 70 - pounders at a lower battery . He also created two batteries on ...
-
Falcon's Cry: A Desert Storm Memoir
By Michael Donnelly, Denise DonnellyU.S. Air Force Major Michael Donnelly was diagnosed with ALS, Lou Gehrig's Disease, after his tour of duty in Desert Storm.
-
Οι επτά ηγέτες του Πολέμου
By Marc Ferro257 ― Bergère MarieClaire, Bianco Lucien και Domes J., La Chine au ΧΧe siècle, 2 τόμοι, Παρίσι, Fayard, 19891990. 258 ― Bergère MarieClaire, Sun YatSen, Παρίσι, Fayard, 1994. 259 ― Bianco Lucien, Les Origines de la révolution chinoise, ...