Seeking Justices: The Judging of Supreme Court Nominees

Description

In the long shadows cast by the Robert Bork and Clarence Thomas nominations, Supreme Court confirmations remain highly contentious and controversial. This is due in part to the Senate's increasing reliance upon a much lengthier, much more public, and occasionally raucous confirmation process—in an effort to curb the potential excesses of executive power created by presidents seeking greater control over the Court's ideological composition. Michael Comiskey offers the most comprehensive, systematic, and optimistic analysis of that process to date.

Arguing that the process works well and therefore should not be significantly altered, Comiskey convincingly counters those critics who view highly contentious confirmation proceedings as the norm. Senators have every right and a real obligation, he contends, to scrutinize the nominees' constitutional philosophies. He further argues that the media coverage of the Senate's deliberations has worked to improve the level of such scrutiny and that recent presidents have neither exerted excessive influence on the appointment process nor created a politically extreme Court. He also examines the ongoing concern over presidential efforts to pack the court, concluding that stacking the ideological deck is unlikely.

As an exception to the rule, Comiskey analyzes in depth the Thomas confirmation to explain why it was an aberration, offering the most detailed account yet of Thomas's pre-judicial professional and political activities. He argues that the Senate Judiciary Committee abdicated its responsibilities out of deference to Thomas's race.

Another of the book's unique features is Comiskey's reassessment of the reputations of twentieth-century Supreme Court justices. Based on a survey of nearly 300 scholars in constitutional law and politics, it shows that the modern confirmation process continues to fill Court vacancies with jurists as capable as those of earlier eras.

We have now seen the longest period without a turnover on the Court since the early nineteenth century, making inevitable the appointment of several new justices following the 2004 presidential election. Thus, the timing of the publication of Seeking Justices could not be more propitious.

Get the book

Amazon.com

Search the book

eBay.com

Search the book

Similar books

• 

  Regulating Commercial Gambling: Past, Present, and Future

  By David Miers

  ... Reginald 184 McKibbin , R. 65 , 217 , 247 , 272 , 273 , 284 Mackintosh , Alphonso 162 Macmillan , Harold 298-9 mains ( dicing game ) 21 managers 200-5 , 400 Masterman , C. E. G. 183 match betting 218 Matthews , Charles 180 Matthews ...

• 

  The Complete American Constitutionalism, Volume Five, Part I: The Constitution of the Confederate States

  By Mark A. Graber, Howard Gillman

  Mark A. Graber, Howard Gillman ... 2 In an introduction to a work subtitled Lessons from the Confederate Constitution that rarely refers to slaves or slavery, Marshall L. DeRosa declares, “the model of government embodied in the CSA ...

• 

  The Papers of John Marshall: Correspondence, papers, and selected judicial opinions, November 1800-March 1807

  By John Marshall, Herbert Alan Johnson, Charles T. Cullen

  12. 1807 Yours of the 3d . Int has been duly received . " The opinions which you give touching the case of Lee & Coulson have been always mine , ever since I examined the case . I now enclose you a Copy of Murdocks deposition .

• 

  Issues in Competition Law and Policy

  196. Id. at 813-16 (Scalia, J., dissenting) (citing Romero v. Int'l Terminal Operating Co., 358 U.S. 354 (1959); Lauritzen v. Larsen, 345 U.S. 571 (1953); Murray v. Schooner Charming Betsy, 6 U.S. (2 Cranch64)(l804)). 197. Id. at 8 1 7.

• 

  人类酷刑史：解密文明面具下的可怖人性

  By 马克·P.唐纳利, 丹尼尔·迪尔

  页末的这幅图片描绘了一个断头台的早期原型,名为“福尔布雷特”(字面意思是“下落的木板”)。在这个刑具中,没有锋利的(甚或金属的)刀片,通过迅速一击来使身首分离;相反,这个刑具只是由几块结实的橡木板构成。在锤击的作用下,厚钝的木板边缘可以砸烂受害者的 ...

• 

  中国禁毒三十年：以刑事规制为主线

  By 高巍

  1962年9月,美国司法部长罗伯特•肯尼迪主持召开“毒品滥用白宫会议”,开始从公众健康导向角度思考吸毒问题,尝试进行毒品贩卖者和毒品成瘾者之间的区分。1965年3月8日,约翰逊总统批准了《1965年药品滥用管制修正案》,对危险药品的非法使用进行严格管制, ...

• 

  The Great Conspiracy Trial: An Essay on Law, Liberty, and the Constitution

  By Jason Epstein

  Trial of the Chicago Eight (or Chicago Seven).

• 

  The Papers of John Marshall: Correspondence and papers, July 1788-December 1795. Account book, July 1788-December 1795

  By John Marshall, Charles T. Cullen, Institute of Early American History and Culture

  Papers of John Marshall: Vol. II: Correspondence and Papers, July 1788-December 1795, and Account Book, July 1788-December 1795

• 

  To the Right Honourable the Lords of Trade and Plantations Supplement to the Reply of His Majesty's Subjects, the Principal...

  By Robert White

  In its determination to preserve the century of revolution, Gale initiated a revolution of its own: digitization of epic proportions to preserve these invaluable works in the largest archive of its kind.

• 

  古典私权一般理论及其对民法体系构造的影响——民法体系的基因解码

  By 杨代雄著

  本书对古典私权一般理论的发展历程进行深入考察，包括考察其思想根源——盛行于17世纪末期至18世纪的德国自然权利义务理论；探究其对民法体系构造的影响，借此揭示潘得克吞式民法体系的形成原因与内在机理。