Michael Moore's Fahrenheit 9/11: How One Film Divided a Nation

Description

In the heat of the 2004 presidential election campaign, no single work of speechmaking, writing, or media production fueled the fiery debate over George W. Bush's leadership as much as Michael Moore's Fahrenheit 9/11. Certainly, no American documentary film ever provoked as much political controversy.

A noted film scholar now offers a much-needed appraisal of both the film and the furor surrounding it. Robert Brent Toplin first examines the development of Moore's ideas and the evolution of his filmmaking, then dissects Fahrenheit 9/11 and explores the many claims and disagreements about the movie's truthfulness. Toplin considers the ways in which Moore based his arguments on a diverse array of "primary sources," many of which had received scant attention in the mainstream media—including the notorious seven-minute "Pet Goat" video depicting President Bush—either deliberately calm or paralyzed—in a Florida classroom on being told of the 9/11 attacks. Finally, Toplin considers the movie's impact, noting that some enthusiasts of the film thought it would help Democrats in the 2004 elections while others argued that Moore's strident approach to issues would turn off swing voters and contribute to a Republican victory.

Critics lambasted Fahrenheit 9/11, claiming Moore violated standards of documentary filmmaking through his excessive partisanship. They also berated him for taking events out of context and getting the facts wrong. Toplin contends that partisanship is a well-established tradition in documentary filmmaking, and he shows that the major disagreements between admirers and detractors of Fahrenheit 9/11 revolved around interpretation rather than the factual record. Michael Moore took some controversial risks, Toplin demonstrates, but on many large and small matters-from his treatment of the Bush administration's reactions to 9/11 and war—making in Iraq to disputes about the Saudi flights from the United States after 9/11—Moore raised many legitimate questions.

Toplin's engaging study shows that Michael Moore's film did more than shake up a nation; it also made an indelible contribution to the esteemed tradition of agenda-driven cinema. Especially in the light of how some of Moore's views have been given added weight by subsequent events, Toplin's book should encourage a new appreciation of Fahrenheit 9/11 and its impact.

Get the book

Amazon.com

Search the book

eBay.com

Search the book

Similar books

• 

  The Man and His Wings: William A. Wellman and the Making of the First Best Picture

  By William A. Wellman

  With Ginger Rogers , Adolphe Menjou , George Montgomery , Lynne Overman , Nigel Bruce , Phil Silvers , Sara Allgood , William Frawley , Spring Byington , Helene Reynolds , George Chandler , George Lessey , Iris Adrian , and Milton ...

• 

  Once Upon a Time in China: A Guide to Hong Kong, Taiwanese, and Mainland Chinese Cinema

  By Jeff Yang

  Armour of God ( 1986 ; Hong Kong , Ac , Cm ) D : Jackie Chan C : Jackie Chan , Alan Tam , Rosamund Kwan , Lola Forner , Bozidar Smiljanic In this flamboyant actioner - clearly inspired by Raiders of the Lost Ark - Chan plays Asian Hawk ...

• 

  Teen Movies: American Youth on Screen

  By Timothy Shary

  ... WOMAN INTO CINEMA Janet McCabe MELODRAMA : GENRE , STYLE , SENSIBILITY John Mercer and Martin Shingler FILM PERFORMANCE : FROM ACHIEVEMENT TO APPRECIATION Andrew Klevan NEW DIGITAL CINEMA : REINVENTING THE MOVING IMAGE Holly Willis ...

• 

  Guide to British Cinema

  By Geoff Mayer

  THE CHALLENGE 59 Greiffer , based on the play by Jacques Gillies ; Cinematography : Arthur Grant ; Music : Wilfred Josephs ; Cast : Peter Cushing ( Fordyce ) , Andre Morell ( Hepburn ) , Richard Vernon ( Pearson ) , Norman Bird ...

• 

  Hollywood Dreams and Biblical Stories

  By Bernard Brandon Scott

  Brandon Scott ' s sage and savvy analysis of more than fifty recent popular American movies , from Dirty Harry to ... BERNARD BRANDON SCOTT is Darbeth Distinguished Professor of New Testament at Phillips Graduate Seminary , Tulsa ...

• 

  1939: Hollywood's Greatest Year

  By Thomas S. Hischak

  Hollywood's Greatest Year Thomas S. Hischak. Published by Rowman & Littlefield A ... British Library Cataloguing in Publication Information Available Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Hischak, Thomas S. author.

• 

  Film Consciousness: From Phenomenology to Deleuze

  By Spencer Shaw

  The first half of the book focuses on understanding the elements of the film experience--and its associated consciousness--through the descriptive tools of phenomenology.

• 

  Looking at Movies: Buch

  By Dave Monahan, Richard Meran Barsam

  Looking at Movies: Buch

• 

  Fashioning Film Stars: Dress, Culture, Identity

  By Rachel Moseley

  Lee's criticisms tap into widely documented histories of black representation within American popular cinema , which have seen white film - makers present black people in ways that are clearly derogatory and two - dimensional .

• 

  I Want to See This Annie Mattygraph: Cartoon History of the Coming of the Movies

  By Stephen Bottomore

  Per tale motivo , nel 1908 in America la Germantown sullo schermo , e mettendosi a cantare sul filo dell'accompagna- Citizens ' Association mise al bando questi copricapi da " vedova mento musicale . Un simile coinvolgimento era ...