The Virtues of Mendacity: On Lying in Politics
- ISBN-10
- 0813929768
- ISBN-13
- 9780813929767
- Category
- Political Science
- Pages
- 264
- Language
- English
- Published
- 2010-05-10
- Publisher
- University of Virginia Press
- Author
- Martin Jay
Description
When Michael Dukakis accused George H. W. Bush of being the "Joe Isuzu of American Politics" during the 1988 presidential campaign, he asserted in a particularly American tenor the near-ancient idea that lying and politics (and perhaps advertising, too) are inseparable, or at least intertwined. Our response to this phenomenon, writes the renowned intellectual historian Martin Jay, tends to vacillate—often impotently—between moral outrage and amoral realism. In The Virtues of Mendacity, Jay resolves to avoid this conventional framing of the debate over lying and politics by examining what has been said in support of, and opposition to, political lying from Plato and St. Augustine to Hannah Arendt and Leo Strauss. Jay proceeds to show that each philosopher’s argument corresponds to a particular conception of the political realm, which decisively shapes his or her attitude toward political mendacity. He then applies this insight to a variety of contexts and questions about lying and politics. Surprisingly, he concludes by asking if lying in politics is really all that bad. The political hypocrisy that Americans in particular periodically decry may be, in Jay’s view, the best alternative to the violence justified by those who claim to know the truth.
Get the book
Other editions
-
- 2010-04-09
- 264 pages
- Paperback
- University of Virginia Press
Similar books
-
Pants on Fire: On Lying in Politics: A Conversation with Martin Jay
By Howard BurtonThis book is based on an in-depth filmed conversation between Howard Burton and renowned intellectual historian Martin Jay, UC Berkeley.
-
Education and the Spirit of Time: Historical, Global and Critical Reflections
By Juha Suoranta, Olli-Pekka Moisio... VIRTUES. OF. MENDACITY. How. Europeans. Taught. (Some. of). Us. to. Learn. to. Love. the. Lies. of. Politics. Toute v ́erit ́e n'est pas bonne `a dire. (French proverb) “Untruth and Consequences” screamed the headline on the cover of the July ...
-
Virtue in Global Governance: Judgment and Discretion
By Jan Klabbers... the “virtues of mendacity”: Jay, Virtues of Mendacity. 126 Mearsheimer, Why Leaders Lie, 105. Note that the reference to “good strategic reasons” presupposes widespread agreement on the eventual goal of the political action concerned ...
-
Reason After Its Eclipse: On Late Critical Theory
By Martin JayFor a more recent appreciation of its argument that ties Becker to postmodernist critiques of the Enlightenment, see Johnson Kent Wright, “The Pre-Postmodernism of Carl Becker,” in Postmodernism and the Enlightenment: New Perspectives ...
-
Essays from the Edge: Parerga and Paralipomena
By Martin Jay17. tony Green, review of Vision and Visuality, and Steven Benson, Blue Book, M/E/A/N/ I/N/G 37 (May 1989). ... David Michael Levin (Cambridge, Ma: Mit Press, 1997), 140. in an essay in the same volume, “Discourse of Vision in ...
-
The Maltese Falcon to Body of Lies: Spies, Noirs, and Trust
By Robert Von Hallberg... The Virtues of Mendacity : On Lying in Poli- tics ( Charlottesville : University of Virginia Press , 2010 ) , 140. Bernard Williams asserts the same starting point : " No one can expect a government to make full disclosure about ...
-
Truth and Democracy
By Andrew Norris, Jeremy ElkinsThe essays in this volume question whether democratic politics requires discussion of truth and, if so, how truth should matter to democratic politics.
-
Political Hypocrisy: The Mask of Power, from Hobbes to Orwell and Beyond
By David RuncimanAnyone discussing political hypocrisy in the future will have to deal with this book.
-
Adman’s Dilemma: From Barnum to Trump
By Paul Rutherford17 18 19 account is found in Herbert W. Hess, “History and Present Status of the 'Truth-in-Advertising' Movement,” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 101 (May 1922): 211–20. Then there are works by scholars: ...
-
Incredible Modernism: Literature, Trust and Deception
By Dr John Attridge, Dr Rod Rosenquist... with respect to which we form countless beliefs, based upon his words and sometimes upon his actions, ... façon d'un afflux de sang à la figure d'une personne quise trouble, à la façon encore d'un silence subit' (3: 88) ['the words ...