The Trouble with Siop(r): How a Behaviorist Framework, Flawed Research, and Clever Marketing Have Come to Define - And Diminish...

Description

Among all the commercial "learning systems" on the market today, how many are advertised as "research-based?" Perhaps it would be easier to count those that are not. Such claims are so widespread that they are seldom taken seriously by experienced educators. At times, however, marketing becomes clever enough to cut through the skepticism. The more extravagant the promises, it seems, the more credible the product becomes. This book tells the story of one such case: the Sheltered Instruction Observation Protocol, or SIOP.(r) Imagine a program developed by an obscure research center. SIOP starts out as a modest tool for evaluating the effectiveness of instruction for children whose English is limited, but soon morphs into something much more ambitious. It now purports to be a detailed "lesson planning and delivery approach" for grades K-12, aligned with state standards and tests. Simultaneously, it outlines a comprehensive design for teacher training and evaluation. Acquired by a major publisher, SIOP is advertised as "field tested ... scientifically validated ... a proven pedagogical approach to teaching both content knowledge and language skills [that] has helped to instruct millions of students." The program's market is expanded far beyond the classrooms of English language learners. It is promoted as an effective model for English-proficient students as well, appropriate not only for K-12 but also for early childhood education, foreign language instruction, GED and adult English programs, and even two-way bilingual education. There are old-time patent medicines that made fewer claims. Is SIOP a truly miraculous pedagogy - good for whatever ails you? Or is it a classic example of "research-based" hype? "The Trouble with SIOP(r)" was inspired by a chorus of complaints from teachers, who are increasingly required to apply the model by top-down directives. Recognizing that SIOP has thus far faced limited critical scrutiny, authors James Crawford and Sharon Adelman Reyes set out to determine: First, is this rigid approach, which requires teachers to incorporate "30 features and eight components" into every lesson, necessary to foster English acquisition and academic achievement? Or does SIOP, as a classic transmission model, impose a straitjacket on creative teaching and learning? Are there better ways to "shelter" and "scaffold" instruction? Second, does this heterogeneous mixture of methodologies and strategies reflect a coherent educational philosophy, consistent with research on second language acquisition? Or is SIOP essentially a grab-bag of "best practices," with a heavy emphasis on behaviorist methods? Finally, does research on this program support the lavish claims made on its behalf? Or is the What Works Clearinghouse at the U.S. Department of Education correct in concluding that none of the studies conducted thus far have demonstrated SIOP's effectiveness? The answers provided by "The Trouble with SIOP(r)" should interest those concerned not only with the education of English language learners, but also with the pernicious impact of commercial pedagogies in American classroom

Get the book

Amazon.com

Search the book

eBay.com

Search the book

Similar books

• 

  Integrating Math and Science in Early Childhood Classrooms Through Big Ideas: A Constructivist Approach

  By SARA DAVIS, Christine Chaillé

  " In this unique book, the authors focus on big ideas-like patterns, transformation, movement, balance, and relationships-as a way to think about content, and they integrate science and mathematics through these big ideas, rather than ...

• 

  A Constructivist Approach to a College Career Exploration Class

  By Lisa A. Spencer

  "Much of career counseling and exploration offered in college settings today is either based on outdated theories developed in the first half of the 20th century or no theory at all (Savickas, 1995).

• 

  学会用技术解决问题: 一个建构主义者的视角

  本书主要阐述的是如何用现代技术帮助学习者进行个人或社会合作建构以及解决问题。全书内容横向涉及问题解决的关键过程,纵向涉及不同的问题解决类型 ...

• 

  Creating Contexts for Learning and Self-authorship: Constructive-developmental Pedagogy

  By Marcia B. Baxter Magolda

  ... 243 Miller , Jean Baker , 225 Kaplan , Alexandria G. , 225 Miller , Theodore K. , 39 Kegan , Robert , 6 , 9 , 10 , 12 , 22 , 23 , Mines , Robert A. , 160 National Association of Student experience ; structure of construc Personnel.

• 

  Teaching Students to Decode the World: Media Literacy and Critical Thinking Across the Curriculum

  By Chris Sperry, Cyndy Scheibe

  This guide to constructivist media decoding explains how all teachers can help students navigate a complex media landscape and productively engage in a democratic society.

• 

  Social Studies for the Elementary and Middle Grades: A Constructivist Approach

  By Cynthia S. Sunal, Mary E. Haas

  Not only will this text guide you to teach social studies within a constructivist framework, but it also models that framework of guided inquiry in the organization of each chapter.

• 

  The Content of Science: A Constructivist Approach to Its Teaching and Learning

  By Peter J. Fensham, Richard F. Gunstone, Richard T. White

  This book is a result of a workshop where 14 science educators were invited to draft chapters on the implications that the research studies in a specific content area of science have for its teaching.

• 

  Meaningful Online Learning: Integrating Strategies, Activities, and Learning Technologies for Effective Designs

  By Jane Howland, Rose M. Marra, Nada Dabbagh

  This volume focuses on balance among learning technologies, instructional strategies, and learning activities in K-12 classrooms, while a companion website provides examples of online learning environments designed to support meaningful ...

• 

  Ramps & Pathways: A Constructivist Approach to Physics with Young Children

  By Rheta DeVries, Christina Sales

  A constructivist approach to physical science

• 

  Construtivismo e ensino de ciências: reflexões epistemológicas e metodológicas

  By Roque Moraes

  ... boas atividades experimentais se fundamentam na solução de problemas , envolvendo questões da realidade dos alunos , que possam ser submetidas a conflitos cognitivos . Desta forma , o ensino de Ciências , integrando teoria e prática ...