Rethinking Victory in Counterinsurgency

ISBN-10
0989439380
ISBN-13
9780989439381
Category
Counterinsurgency
Pages
29
Language
English
Published
2014-11-06
Authors
Army War College, Michael C. Griffin

Description

Americans are averse to war and easily frustrated with wars of limited objectives. As such, Americans have a cultural aversion to counterinsurgency (COIN). Moreover, Americans have grown to expect total victory in the form of unconditional surrender as the termination of any conflict. We consider anything less as a loss or stalemate. The nature of COIN is inherently political, eighty percent political and twenty percent military. It has been said that there cannot be a purely military solution to an insurgency because insurgency is not a primarily military activity. As such, the use of the term "victory" as a description of the termination of conflict when the U.S. involves itself in COIN is problematic. The political nature of COIN and the American way of viewing war and termination of conflict require that we adopt a new definition of "victory" in a COIN operation. The term "victory," as the term is classically defined and as viewed by Americans, does not fit in COIN planning or execution owing to the nature of the objective in a COIN operation. In any conflict, the definition of what constitutes "victory" and who defines "victory" can remain fluid and this is especially true in COIN. A comparison of the British experience in Northern Ireland, which many consider victory, to the U.S. experience in Iraq, which many consider a loss, demonstrates the need for a better definition for the termination of a COIN operation. Based on analysis of the outcomes of historical case studies of COIN operations and what portends to be the future of warfare, this paper argues that we create a definition of "success" for the termination of a COIN operation and replace the term "victory" in COIN in the military's vocabulary.

Get the book

Amazon.com
Amazon.com
Search the book
eBay.com
eBay.com
Search the book

Other editions

Similar books

  • Got Vision?: Unity of Vision in Policy and Strategy : what it Is, and why We Need it
    Got Vision?: Unity of Vision in Policy and Strategy : what it Is, and why We Need it
    By Anna Simons

    35 Maybe it is not fair to blame T. E. Lawrence for this paradox—of reducible but unduplicable insight. 36 Lawrence was, after all, quite specific that his “Twenty-seven Articles,” which represented his compilation of what worked among ...

  • Rand Counterinsurgency Study
    Rand Counterinsurgency Study
    By Bruce Pirnie

    This monograph outlines strategic considerations relative to counterinsurgency (COIN) campaigns; presents an overview of the current conflict in Iraq, focusing on COIN; analyzes COIN operations in Iraq; presents conclusions about...

  • The Making of the SAS and the World's Elite Forces
    The Making of the SAS and the World's Elite Forces
    By Terry White

    On 21 February , Henry Hogan and Declan Martin spotted the SAS hide . Requesting orders , they were told to capture the soldiers that night . The SAS men were taken by surprise from the rear and , as they The SAS have always operated in ...

  • When the United States Invaded Russia: Woodrow Wilson's Siberian Disaster
    When the United States Invaded Russia: Woodrow Wilson's Siberian Disaster
    By Carl J. Richard

    2, 62; Woodrow Wilson to Robert Lansing, April 29, 1918, vol. 2, 144; Link, Papers of Woodrow Wilson, Sir Cecil Rice to the Foreign Office, December 27, 1917, vol. 45, 370; December 29, 1917, vol. 45, 393; Lord Robert Cecil to the ...

  • Resolving Insurgencies
    Resolving Insurgencies
    By Thomas R. Mockaitis

    See Robert Taber, The War of the Flea: A Study of Guerrilla Warfare Theory and Practice, New York: Potomac Books, 2002; ... Myth of the Guerrilla: Revolutionary Theory and Malpractice, New York: Knopf, 1971, challenges Taber's argument.

  • The Phoenix Program
    The Phoenix Program
    By Douglas Valentine

    Though carefully documented, the book is written in an accessible style that makes it ideal for readers at all levels, from undergraduates to professional historians.

  • Counterinsurgency Wars and the Anglo-American Alliance: The Special Relationship on the Rocks
    Counterinsurgency Wars and the Anglo-American Alliance: The Special Relationship on the Rocks
    By Andrew Mumford

    Busch, All the Way with JFK?, 84. 22. McGeorge Bundy, oral history interview #3, John F. Kennedy Presidential Library Digital Oral History Program, http://archive2.jfklibrary.org/JFKOH/Bundy, %20McGeorge/JFKOH-MGB-03/JFKOH-MGB-03-TR.pdf ...

  • U.S. Army Counterinsurgency and Contingency Operations Doctrine: 1942-1976 (Paperbound)
    U.S. Army Counterinsurgency and Contingency Operations Doctrine: 1942-1976 (Paperbound)
    By Andrew James Birtle

    Lawrence Yates , Power Pack : U.S. Intervention in the Dominican Republic ( Fort Leavenworth , Kans .: Combat Studies Institute , 1988 ) , pp . 14–66 ; Blechman and Kaplan , Force Without War , pp . 291–93 , 303–08 ; Lawrence Greenberg ...

  • The Political Impossibility of Modern Counterinsurgency: Strategic Problems, Puzzles, and Paradoxes
    The Political Impossibility of Modern Counterinsurgency: Strategic Problems, Puzzles, and Paradoxes
    By David Martin Jones, M. L. R. Smith

    Through an extensive investigation into COIN's theories, methods, and outcomes, this book undermines enduring claims about COIN's success while revealing its hidden meanings and effects.

  • Jane's Police and Security Equipment
    By Charles Heyman

    Providing access to the capabilities of the world's leading police and security equipment and their suppliers, this guide reviews over 1300 items, including secure communications, access control, surveillance equipment, firearms and ...