Exceptional Vengeance: Revenge and the Rule of Law in Nineteenth-century American Literature

ISBN-10: 1267380381
ISBN-13: 9781267380388
Category: Indians in literature
Pages: 357
Language: English
Published: 2012
Author: Lisa Michelle Thomas

Description

People often characterize revenge as unlawful and undesirable because it challenges the primacy of mercy, forgiveness, proportionality, and deterrence. Relying in part on the theories of Giorgio Agamben, Michel Foucault, Jacques Derrida, Carl Schmitt, and Walter Benjamin, I examine how nineteenth-century authors in the Americas treat revenge as a potentially law-making, law-preserving, and law-challenging form of violence. Specifically, the texts I analyze from the 1830s to 1850s employ the notion of exceptionalism to suggest that revenge is justified and even sometimes necessary for purportedly heroic protagonists when established law is in flux, is absent, or is unreliable--especially in borderlands or frontier spaces and during wartime. The authors have their individual protagonists rewrite law and act as sovereigns, blending biblical interpretations, natural law, lex talionis, and other beliefs to impose particular kinds of order on these exceptional locations and moments. In Chapter 1, I examine William Gilmore Simms's The Yemassee and how frontier romance authors generally depict Natives as vengeful, untrustworthy savages and whites as defenders of self and nation. In Chapter 2, I discuss how retellings of Hannah Duston's captivity and Robert Montgomery Bird's Nick of the Woods celebrate the acts of unlikely, feminized heroes as they kill and mutilate Native Americans. Chapter 3 focuses on the Parker captivities in Texas and George Lippard's 'Bel of Prairie Eden, wherein white, male Texans are depicted as defenders of white women's virtue and go on vengeful quests against the Comanche and Mexicans (respectively), ultimately exhibiting some ambivalence about whether revenge is fulfilling and justified. Finally, in Chapter 4 I analyze Maxwell Philip's Emmanuel Appadocca, the story of a black, Trinidadian pirate who challenges the rule of law and readers' ability to accept a mixed-race hero who uses his pirate ship and the space of the ocean to write revenge into law. This study informs scholarship on law and justice, race and gender, and American exceptionalism by linking literary studies to legal and political philosophy and considering revenge as a specific kind of violence that, when justified by individual authors and their protagonists, has had great effects on past and present politics.

Get the book

Similar books

Leslie Marmon Silko: A Collection of Critical Essays
By Louise K. Barnett, James L. Thorson
An exciting collection of new essays on the work of the outstanding American Indian woman writer.
Fifty Years After The Big Sky: New Perspectives on the Fiction and Films of A.B. Guthrie, Jr
By William E. Farr, William W. Bevis
Each man kills the thing he loves . No man ever did it more thoroughly or in a shorter time than the fur hunters . ... profit while wiping out the beaver , I would be delighted for everyone to believe that we must kill what we love .
Hidden Treasures of the American West: Muriel H. Wright, Angie Debo, and Alice Marriott
By Patricia Loughlin
Boston : Little , Brown , 1935 . Scanlon , Jennifer , and Sharon Cosner . American Women Historians , 1700-1990s . Westport , CT : Greenwood Press , 1996 . Scharff , Virginia . Twenty Thousand Roads : Women , Movement , and the West .
Reader's Guide to Blood Meridian
By Shane Schimpf
A Reader's Guide to Blood Meridian is the essential companion to the classic novel by Cormac McCarthy. Every reader, whether a student of literature or a fan of the book, will find a wealth of information in these pages.
Hard Traveling Down the Red Dirt Road: Exploring Working-class Issues in Louise Erdrich's Love Medicine and the Bingo Palace
By Kristy L. Pastore
This research fills a gap in Erdrich scholarship because there few sources that analyze and interpret these novels as working-class literature.
Literature Help: The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-time Indian
By Students' Academy
It was Alexie's first young adult novel. Alexie is a screenwriter, stand-up comedian, songwriter, and a film producer. Before writing this novel, the author had already written adult novel, poems, screenplays, and short stories.
Injun
By Jordan Abel
Injun
Indios en escena: la representación del amerindio en el teatro del Siglo de Oro
By Moisés R. Castillo
These works consistently raise the paradoxical question of how a person can be a savage and have honor at the same time.
IMAGINING INDIANS SW PB
By DILWORTH L
In Imagining Indians in the Southwest, Leah Dilworth examines the creation and enduring potency of the early twentieth-century myth of the primitive Indian.
Literarische Begegnungen mit dem Fremden: intranationale und internationale Vermittlung kultureller Alterität am Beispiel des Erzählwerks Miguel Angel Asturias'
By Carina Welly
... Transatlantische Perzeptionen : Latein- amerika - USA - Europa in Geschichte und Gegenwart . Stuttgart : Heinz , 1998 ( Histora- mericana ; 6 ) KÖNIG , Hans - Joachim : ,, Entstehen , Fortwirken und Wandlungen der Amerikabilder im ...