Time, Space, and Number in Physics and Psychology (Psychology Revivals)

ISBN-10: 1317557549
ISBN-13: 9781317557548
Category: Psychology
Pages: 188
Language: English
Published: 2014-10-14
Publisher: Psychology Press
Author: William R. Uttal

Description

The crux of the debate between proponents of behavioral psychology and cognitive psychology focuses on the issue of accessibility. Cognitivists believe that mental mechanisms and processes are accessible, and that their inner workings can be inferred from experimental observations of behavior. Behaviorists, on the contrary, believe that mental processes and mechanisms are inaccessible, and that nothing important about them can be inferred from even the most cleverly designed empirical studies. One argument that is repeatedly raised by cognitivists is that even though mental processes are not directly accessible, this should not be a barrier to unravelling the nature of the inner mental processes and mechanisms. Inference works for other sciences, such as physics, so why not psychology? If physics can work so successfully with their kind of inaccessibility to make enormous theoretical progress, then why not psychology? As with most previous psychological debates, there is no "killer argument" that can provide an unambiguous resolution. In its absence, author William Uttal explores the differing properties of physical and psychological time, space, and mathematics before coming to the conclusion that there are major discrepancies between the properties of the respective subject matters that make the analogy of comparable inaccessibilities a false one. This title was first published in 2008.

Get the book

Other editions

Time, Space, and Number in Physics and Psychology (Psychology Revivals)
- 2014-10-14
- 188 pages
- Ebook
- Psychology Press
Time, Space, and Number in Physics and Psychology (Psychology Revivals)
- 2014-09-22
- 204 pages
- Paperback
- Psychology Press

Similar books

Time, Space, and Number in Physics and Psychology
By William R. Uttal
As with most previous psychological debates, there is no killer argument that can provide an unambiguous resolution.In its absence, author William Uttal explores the differing properties of physical and psychological time, space, and ...
Empathy I (Psychology Revivals)
By Joseph D. Lichtenberg, Donald Silver, Melvin Bornstein
... physics, too, has progressed decisively by relegating the relevance of certain constituents of its observational and explanatory framework which up to now had held unlimited sway, such as time, space, and causality, to certain clearly ...
Bertrand Russell's Dialogue with His Contemporaries (Routledge Revivals)
By Elizabeth Ramsden Eames
... Prophecy and Dissent 1914–16, ed. Richard A. Rempel with Margaret Moran. London: George Allen & Unwin, Ltd., 1983, 1984, 1986, 1988, 1985, 1988, respectively. A Critical Exposition of the Philosophy of Leibniz with an Appendix of ...
Revival: Philosophy and the Physicists (1937)
By Lizzie Susan Stebbing
Lizzie Susan Stebbing. me much in conversation , especially my friend Miss Margaret Willis , who asked me difficult questions , some of which I have tried to answer in this book in a manner worthy of her honesty of mind .
Empathy II (Psychology Revivals)
By Joseph D. Lichtenberg, Donald Silver, Melvin Bornstein
... space and time , independent of observation ; further , that space and time were categories of classification of all ... physics , whose natural consequence was the scientific concept of the universe of the nineteenth century , was first ...
Behaviour (Psychology Revivals)
By D. E. Broadbent
... physics considers cases in which even three-dimensional space behaves in a non-Euclidean way, as though it were ... time went on (to account for the facts of forgetting) but the decay with time was assumed to be fairly slow. Even quite a ...
Revival: An Outline of Psychology (1968)
By Willam McDougall
For the beginning of this cycle of activity is, so far as we can see, determined by no change in the environment, but only by the maturing of the instincts. During this period of youth the wasp is actuated in the main by the instinct of ...
Revival: The Psychology of Reasoning (1923)
By Eugenio Rignano
... the future external circumstances which the animal unconsciously prepares itself to face with the complex behaviour that instinct dictates, such and such a peculiarity of environment relatively to which the organ fashioned by the ...
How the Hippies Saved Physics: Science, Counterculture, and the Quantum Revival
By David Kaiser
like Leonard Schiff's successful Quantum Mechanics. The Berkeley physicist had used the first edition, from 1949, as a student, and he looked back on it fondly. “The book kept me sufficiently busyto prevent pseudophilosophical ...
The Persistent Problems of Psychology
By Robert Brodie MacLeod
The Persistent Problems of Psychology