The career of Sir James Dowling, second Chief Justice of NSW (1837-1844), supplies a model of the working of patronage in the appointment of judges to British colonial service. Dowling's advancement as puisne judge in Sydney, as acting Chief Justice during the absence on leave of Chief Justice Forbes, and a Chief Justice in succession to Forbes, depended on patrons. The principal was Lord Brougham, supported in England by Dowling's influential journalist brother Vincent.While he was not an outstanding judicial lawyer, Dowling was painstaking and industrious. His meticulous manuscript recording of court proceedings was an astonishing undertaking. This book reviews his contribution as judge and as ex officio Legislative Councillor. It traces prolonged litigation, disposed of before Dowling, concerning the proprietor of the Sydney Monitor, Edward Smith Hall. And it examines the bruising relations between Dowling and fellow judges W W Burton and J W Willis.The NSW State Set of Lives of Australian Chief Justices, which includes, Sir Francis Forbes, Sir James Dowling, Sir Alfred Stephen, Sir James Martin and Sir Frederick Darley is available for $210.00 - to order the NSW State Set, click here.CORRIGENDUMIn this title, Sir James Dowling, the material "Dramatis Personae" contains an error. The entry "HOWICK" should be omitted and the entry "GREY" should read:GREY, Sir George, Under Secretary (Political) for the Colonies, 1834-1835, 1835-1839.
... Sir Francis Forbes Sir James Dowling Sir James Martin Queensland Sir James Cockle South Australia Sir Charles Cooper Tasmania Sir John Pedder Victoria Sir William a Beckett Sir William Stawell Western Australia Sir Archibald Burt ...
Notwithstanding which, McInnes was later called upon to answer, in court, a formal charge of committing perjury in the very same affidavit. Leave to file the application having been granted, but not acted upon, the Attorney-General ...
Bruce Kercher examines the challenges Dowling faced in adapting English law to the new colony, in particular regarding a person's legal status as an Aborigine, convict or free subject of the King.
This book gives closer attention to those early years than has any previous account, as his reputation for probity and ability, already well established before he came to Sydney, was the antithesis of the bad character attributed to him by ...
J M Bennett's Sir Frederick Darley, the new biography in his acclaimed Lives of the Australian Chief Justices series, describes in fascinating detail one of the most extraordinary episodes in Australian judicial history.